N.B. The following text in this blog-post Goldfinch: Symbol for Resurrection is Copyright © 2012 Philip Johnson.
GOLDFINCH: SYMBOL FOR RESURRECTION
In his original study of the Goldfinch in European art, the ornithologist Herbert Friedmann (1946:7-9) wrote that this bird has several symbolic meanings ascribed to it. The four principal symbolic meanings all link up to important biblical things including: the soul, sacrifice, death, and Resurrection. Another symbol that the Goldfinch stood for was recovery from illness, and the raising up of a person out of their sick-bed was another kind of symbolic Resurrection.
Image Source: http://www.birdforum.net/opus/Image:European_Goldfinch.jpgIt was during the Renaissance, that the European Goldfinch (Genus: Carduelis; species Carduelis carduelis) became associated in paintings with important theological symbols such as the Passion of Christ and the Resurrection.How that came about involves a retrospective kind of tale about the Goldfinch and the Passion of Christ. The legend endeavours to explain both the distinctive red markings on the Goldfinch’s head, and its diet of eating thistle and thorns.
A Passion Legend
A post-biblical legend developed about the goldfinch being a witness to the humiliating march of Jesus carrying the cross to Golgotha. A goldfinch flew above the staggering figure of Jesus and was distressed by the crown of thorns on his head. As the legend tells it, the goldfinch flew down and tried to pluck off the thorns. As the bird plucked at thorns some of Jesus’ blood dripped onto the goldfinch’s head. Hence the origin of the red feathers on its head is explained as originating from this event.
Its natural diet of consuming thorns and thistles is also enlisted in the details of the tale, to emphasise that in the tragedy of Jesus’ torture and execution that even animals bore witness.
George Ferguson (1961:19) remarks:
The goldfinch is fond of eating thistles and thorns, and since al thorny plants have been accepted as an allusion to Christ’s crown of thorns, the goldfinch has become an accepted symbol of the Passion of christ. In this sense, it frequently appears with the Christ Child, showing the close connection between the Incarnation and Passion.
Image Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Raffael_031.jpg
Painting: Madonna of the Goldfinch by Raphael (c.1505-06).
These two points about plucking the thorns and being stained in red blood became of interest to Renaissance painters.
Friedmann (1946) discussed some four hundred and eighty-six paintings that feature the Goldfinch. Some two hundred and fifty-four artists used the Goldfinch in Christian devotional paintings. Among the notable painters are Leonardo da Vinci (Madonna Litta, 1490–1491), Raphael (Solly Madonna, 1502, and Madonna of the Goldfinch, 1506), Zurbarán (Madonna and Child with the Infant St John, 1658) and Tiepolo (Madonna of the Goldfinch, 1760).
On the Goldfinch as a symbol of the Resurrection, Friedmann (1946:7-8) states:
The goldfinch symbolizes Resurrection. This meaning is perhaps more intimately connected with the barn swallow than with any other single species of bird but is shared in by the goldfinch, the linnet, and by other forms as well. In the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries when interest in the apocryphal books of the Bible flourished so greatly, artists were quick to seize upon the aesthetic possibilities involved in the various legends thereby made known. One of these, the “Pseudo-Matthew Legend”, was that of the Christ Child playing with toy or clay birds which His companions brought to Him, and which He miraculously brought to life. This bringing to life quickly came to stand for the idea of Resurrection. The swallow, long considered as a sign of spring, of the rebirth of the year, was assumed to hibernate in the mud through the winter and then become revitalized with the advent of warm weather. The similarity between the idea of the dormant mud-encrusted swallow and the clay bird is obvious. Its connection with the Resurrection theme (and thereby with Christ) led to its being called in parts of Germany the “Madonna Bird”.
Sheridan Germann and Richard Rephanna (1995: 29) remark that the manufacture of the musical instrument the harpsichord in seventeenth century Holland involved it being decorated with symbols of the resurrection. This included the Goldfinch:
The goldfinch, often found as a resurrection symbol in vanitas still-life paintings occurred frequently on soundboards. Resurrection symbolism may have seemed particularly appropriate on musical instruments since the wood of the dead tree finds new life and voice in music. A motto sometimes found on musical instruments gave voice to this thought in the words ‘Dum vixi tacui, mortua dulce cano’ (in life I was silent; in death I sweetly sing).
As I will discuss in a future post, the symbolism of animals as signs of the Resurrection need to be seen as part of a wider stream of thought involving the future redemption and resurrection of animals (includes desert fathers and medieval saints signifying the peaceable kingdom in their contact with wild animals; reports of saints raising animals from the dead; and the fulfilment of prophecy concerning the new earth).
George Ferguson (1961). Signs and Symbols in Christian Art (London & Oxford:Oxford University Press).
Herbert Friedmann (1946). The Symbolic Goldfinch: Its History and Significance in European Devotional Art (The Bollingen Series VII. Washington DC: Pantheon Books).
Sheridan Germann & Richard Rephann (1995). The Historical Harpsichord: Harpsichord Decoration and the Yale Taskin (Hillsdale, New York: Pendragon).
Pingback: Harpsichord: A Symbol of the Resurrection | The Cross Is Not Enough
Pingback: goldfinches in avignon « anny evason artlog
Thanks for commenting. Yes, resurrection symbolism is not the only category, which I noted in my first paragraph and the various symbolic meanings concerning the Passion, Soul etc are also discussed at length in Friedmann’s work.
I enjoyed reading this article on the Goldfinch. Today, this bird holds a special place in my heart.
I know this is an older blog, but I had been seeing or hearing a lot about goldfinches. During a google search, I came across your piece. What a pleasant surprise! It was confirmation of a promise and a prayer. Thank you for writing this.
Recently the morning after a coworker had passed away I had a goldfinch sit on the window ledge of my drivers side door of my truck. He stayed for about 5 minutes. I took photos of him with my cell phone and sent them to my daughters and wife. Then I looked up the meaning of this visit and read about the goldfinches removing the thorns from Jesus’s head and that the sighting meant live life to the fullest. The goldfinch that visited me was a northern one, however it still makes you think about a message being sent. I have never spotted one in the parking lot of my job in 31 years.
A great article which I so enjoyed reading, especially as I saw some of Michelangelo and Sebastiano’s depictions of the goldfinch today in exactly the context you describe. Would you mind if I re-blogged it on my site, http://www.gordonlthomas.com ?
Hi Gordon, feel free to do so
Wow, I have been seeing them around my house, have a figurine of one on my windowsill, and remember writing a report on the Goldfinch when in grade school. After reading your article, and some themes God has been speaking to my heart in private devotional, this is confirmation to me personally. Wow. Thanks again for sharing!
Reblogged this on Gordon L. Thomas and commented:
A very interesting blog, especially if you a fond of goldfinches! Lovely Jan and I are and see many in our garden!